Sherrydough.com

51 W Main Street, New Palestine, IN 46163

Order Online for Pick-Up at the Bakery

I'm looking forward to seeing you at the bakery in New Palestine.

OPEN HOURS...

Tuesday; Noon - 5pm

Wednesday; 9am - Noon / 3pm - 5pm

Thursday; 9am - Noon / 3pm - 6pm

Friday; 9am - 2pm

Saturday; 8am - Noon

Please visit this page for updates to our hours.

We'll be making a variety of things daily, so please order online for specific requests.

Sherry

Donuts - YES DONUTS!

By popular request, we are bringing donuts to Sherrydough. Occassionally, we will make and serve our own SHERRYDOUGH made sourdough cake donuts, but for now, and for your donut partaking pleasure, we have partnered with a local bakery to bring you good ole yeast donuts with no preservatives! We will begin serving a variety of donuts on Saturdays only, and will increase availability, and variety, per your request. ENJOY!!

Let customers speak for us

from 31 reviews

Outstanding

The best!

Tom Vail

01/10/2026

Sourdough Sandwich Loafs

Absolutely wonderful

Absolutely wonderful. Delicious moist flavorful. Hard to not stop in every day they are open...

Alice Hedden

12/31/2025

Sourdough Cranberry Orange Scones

The bread tastes great but was a bit underdone

The bread tastes great but was a bit underdone.
The website ordering and paying was easy but then ithe process and communication became frustrating.
I received a confirmation email for my order indicating I would be notified when it was ready for pickup..
The confirmation email said I would need to pick up my order somewhere other than your shop in New Palestine which wasn’t something I’d not been informed about. The confirmation did not have any phone contact info for questions or follow up. The order was to be completed prior to Thanksgiving but I had not received any notification as of 12 noon prior to that date. Luckily I stopped in the shop and the bread was ready! I did have to wait for my loaves to be
sliced though. I also suggest investing in a slicing machine bcause the slices were very uneven.
I will chalk up my issues to the newness of the business and working out any kinks. I think the breads are good and wish success for Sherrydough!

Jane Miessen

11/29/2025